Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza

The food here is absolutely delicious, and the pizza is among the best you will find anywhere on Staten Island. The environment and decor are perfect, and the staff are super friendly. The service was particularly quick (though not so quick that we felt rushed). The only thing stopping this from being a five star review is that the draught beer selection is really not great.

Excellent Vodka Pizza. Mussels Mariana is a bit on the salty side but very fresh. Turtufa (?) is delicious and not super sweet. Super friendly staff. Highly recommend.

Delivery came 30 minutes late and the driver was waiting in front of the wrong house, had to walk all the way there to get the food. It’s called delivery for a reason.

By far the best pizza on Staten Island! Consistently. Our family has been coming here for years and it just seems to get better every time. Now we get a homemade brick oven bread as soon as you sit down? Yes please! Fresh ingredients, great brick oven taste, and phenomenal service. Can't wait until my next visit.

This restaurant is my favorite restaurant. Of all restaurants I know I favor it most. I never miss an opportunity to go to visit this place. everytime I feel like having a special meal, this place comes right away to my head. exeptionalgorgeous and diverse food and a large list of dishes.courteous team, and great mood. Also important, the price is honest. I recommend this spot with no doubt.

To understand New Yorker's attitude towards pizza, bring your virgin to Goodfella's! The pizza tasted better than the pizza I remember while growing up in Staten Island. It is the flavor that can not be recreated anywhere else! Now residing in the south, my bucket list included sharing that special pizza flavor with others. Goodfella's Brick Oven Pizza gets 5 stars in all categories!

This is the best place to have brick oven pizza or any other dish that is on their menu. We are going tonight to try their steak. Atmosphere is relaxed, servers are very friendly and very accommodating on any dish even if it is not on the menu. Portions are large and price is decent. Please go and check them out you wont regret it. I am happy we found a go to place for lunch or dinner :)

Nice staff and really fast serving entire dinner at once.

GREAT PIZZA, GREAT PRICE AND GREAT SERVICE !! RECENTLY TRIED THE BROOKLYN FINEST PIZZA AND IT CAN’T COMPARE TO GOODFELLAS !! GOODFELLAS ONE LOVE ❤️❤️

Great pizza, I order the chicken francese was cooked to perfection and the pizza CRUSTACEAN SENSATION was absolutely delicious.... great service , must visit for anyone wanting great Italian food and pizza

Great Food..

Goodfellas was recommended by one of my wife's friends who is originally from Staten Island. We ordered the cold antipasto and pizza. The antipasto was outstanding with the fresh mozzarella, olives, prosciutto, and dressing. The pizza was delicious with its sauce and crust. Also, the staff was awesome. When I come back to Staten Island, I am going to eat here again. Highly recommend!

Amazing pizzeria! Service is very efficient, friendly & knowledgeable. Food is great and decor is amazing. I definitely recommend to anyone!

This pizza and place are world class! 100% Best pizza around. Pizza is light, crispy, full of beautiful flavors(they are all good) and made with love. Chicken Parmesan is like Nona made it Sunday after church. Pasta so so good!! Everything is pure awesomeness here. Atmosphere is Great for families, date night or just popping in and grabbing a pie. Don’t waist your time going anywhere else. This place is the best!

Great place homie. Place I can eat. Fantastik waitor.

Have not had such a grate Pizza in years. Thank you guys. You made my Friday.

Honestly, no joke, I've gotta say this was the best pizza experience I've had. It came fast, service was fantastic, and the pizza was seriously the most incredible combination of flavors: sun-dried tomatoes, artichokes, mushrooms, fresh mozzarella, and the best sauce I've ever tasted. I'm a fan! The cheesecake was a no-brainer! Perfect meal! Can't wait to visit again!

Everything was excellent tonight. My group of 3 all had something different and we all enjoyed it. The lobster ravioli with shrimp was a hit. My pizza with ricotta and meatball (I got a large so I'd have a few slices tomorrow for lunch) was made just right. Pleasant service and a nice, bustling atmosphere. Go and enjoy.

Best pizza hands down! Their brick oven pizza is to die for! From the dough to the sauce and cheese, all of the ingredients perfectly compliment one another. Whether you are near by or have to go on a mission to stop by their shop, it is definitely a must to visit them!

Awesome food and great atmosphere. You need to come and experience it.

Best pizza for a reason

Great pizza, very delicious. Good variety of sauces and toppings, I had vodka sauce pizza which was fantastic.! Also, very good appetizers! We were a party of 6. We all enjoyed the pizza and food. Very large portions! First time there, we will definitely go back.

I loved their bruschetta... such a great find... pizza pie was brick oven fresh...Waitress was ultra nice and helpful in anything requested...Only wished I lived close enuf to go there more often....

I meet a friend of mine at goodfellas every time he visits- we have a mushroom pizza & a vodka pizza- so delicious every time- all fresh ingredients. Scott’s always great to us when we come by.

Great food. Good pizza. I definitely recommend eating here. Service can be slow, regardless it's a great dinner date..

They invented the Vodka pizza. They’ve won multiple awards for “Best Pizza”. They teach students all over the world how to make pizza. Come here. Eat the pizza. Feel satiated.

They boast about all their awards for their pizza, and rightly so. The service is is just as good. We were there near opening on a Saturday and were greeted like old friends even though we had never been there before. I wish we had a pizza joint like this near home.

Great pizza pretty good other foods also

I have been a very satisfied customer of Goodfellas for over twenty years. The quality and taste of their food has been consistently good throughout that time. As someone raised by an Italian mother with very particular taste in Italian food, these guys hit the ball out of the park every time! Highly recommended!

Everything is so darn good! Literally everything I've had from them has been so ridiculously tasty, down to the fresh bread and oil they sit in front of you while you're waiting for your food. The waitress we had was phenomenal, friendly and attentive without being at all overbearing. We will be back. Mark my words lol

Got the old world pizza for delivery. Wasn’t particularly wow’ed but maybe it’s better for sit down 🤷🏽‍♀️

Pizza and wings were extremely delicious! Very impressed. Def good pizza on the island

The fettuccine Alfredo was good, hint of garlic. Only complaint is that the grilled chicken was cut up into less than bite size pieces...

This was our first time here, I saw the name of the restaurant passing by and just had to come and try it out. We were a table of 4 and ordered a few pies, pastas and an appetizer. The food was good but the marinara sauce on the pasta and the appetizer was just so bland for all 4 of us, my 11 year old said it tastes like nothing. Maybe the batch wasn’t good as always? I’d come back though and try some other stuff. OH and the seafood pie I wouldn’t recommend, it was just too fishy, but that’s just a preference.

The aesthetics of the place is nice and the service was great. I really liked the pizza I ordered but the pasta was alright. Regardless if you're around and hungry, this place is worth if.

Pizza is huge and delicious. Good place to go for some authentic looking italian food.

Had the lemon chicken pizza. It sets the standard for creative and delicious pizza on Staten Island. Crust is thin and crispy yet will not crumble. Just walking in you get the rich aroma and ambiance of a great American pizza place. Our server was attentive and polite, never had to ask for more water. One of my favorite spots.

Pizza alla Vodka pie. It won some awards in the past. I enjoyed it.

So many cars in Staten Island! But the pizza is great. Better yet, the staff was very friendly and knew what to suggest. Nice room, excellent food, unpretentious. Wish we had such a place in Jersey City, don't get me started on Razza.

Ordered veal francese, the veal was so tough and chewy. Waiter wanted to give another but it's probably the same. My husband ordered eggplant parm, got chicken parm, waiter said he ordered chicken. He said he'll get the eggplant. He came and was so small ....2 slices wasn't even cooked mozz. wasn't melted.

Came here for a Christmas party and Goodfellas did not disappoint. The appetizers were flavorful and delicious; the fried calamari was crispy and seasoned to perfection. As a entree I had the baked salmon with wilted spinach and golden roasted potatoes. The salmon was cooked to a perfect medium-well and was as succulent as ever

Very good food and very good service. My friend and I were treated like royalty while we dined there earlier. Would gladly go back again!

A Staten Island institution, Goodfellas reminds diners of what old-school New York was like. With waiters that have that stereotypical Italian-New Yorker accent to a neighborhood pizza joint vibe (and prices to match!) this fantastic restaurant creates phenomenal food with a comfortable feel.Go for the Goodfella, their namesake pie, topped generously with their famous sauce and plenty of fresh mozzerella, roasted peppers, sausage, and garlic.

Took my family here for dinner. Great food, atmosphere and especially great service! Highly recommend and will be back soon!

Their standards are not stable. sometimes you get very ,very good food. Othertimes just regular, and nothing special. Maybe the chef is not in on those off days.

EXCELLENT pizza and customer service! I ordered online and they accidentally forgot the salad dressing. I called and they were more than accommodating sending another salad with extra dressing and a dessert. We will be ordering from here a lot!!

So much food for a good price. Staff is attentive and nice. Food is fresh and tasty. Pizza is also great.

Nice, quiet dinning room with dim lighting. Friendly server. They even offered us free samples.

First time order from there Pizza was so good. Definitely need to go for dinner there!!!

I have been coming to this goodfellas since they opened over 20 years ago. Never disappoint. I'll be going back every chance I get.